$
“Worth every slice.”

Crash Course for Founders · Capstone · Slice 3 of 6

Your first round: a smaller slice of a bigger pizza

Is dilution bad news? WhatsApp’s founders sold slices and still kept most of the pizza.

November 20264 min read

This article uses a corporation. An LLCA limited liability company, owned by members who hold units instead of stock. LLCs are usually taxed as partnerships, with their own rules. uses units instead of shares, but the math works the same way. The numbers are made up to keep the math simple.

The $19 billion app that skipped the fundraising treadmill

The standard startup advice is to raise as much money as possible. WhatsApp didn’t. Through 2013, WhatsApp raised about $60 million, all from one venture firm. In 2014, Facebook agreed to buy WhatsApp for about $19 billion.1 Sequoia’s first check, $8 million, came in 2011. Two years later came about $52 million more, and Sequoia reportedly ended up with around 20 percent.2 One investor holding about a fifth still left most of the pizza with the founders and the team. Forbes estimated that co-founder Jan Koum alone owned about 45 percent at the $19 billion sale.3 The founders did not give up many slices and still got a far bigger pizza. So how does a round change your slice?

What happens at a round?

At the start, Boop Snoot, Inc. is worth $8. The company has 8 shares, counting the 2 in the option pool, so each is worth $1. Giggly Tickly’s 3 shares are worth $3.

The start“8 shares, $1 each.”The whole company is worth $8
Giggly Tickly’s slice3 shares, worth $3

At the Series AUsually a startup’s first large priced round of venture money, after any seed round., investors value the companyWhat investors agree the company is worth. Pre-money is before the new cash. Post-money includes the new cash. Either sets the share price for that round. at $100, counting their new money. That’s the post-money valuation. Boop Snoot, Inc., issues 2 new shares, so there are now 10. That makes each share worth $10. Investors buy the 2 new shares at $10 each.

Series A“We value you at $100.”Investors buy 2 new shares
10 shares nowThe company is worth $100
Giggly Tickly’s sliceStill 3 shares, now worth $30

Giggly Tickly’s slice shrank from 37.5% to 30%. The pizza grew from $8 to $100. Her slice is worth 10 times more.

StageGiggly Tickly’s sliceWorth on paper
Start37.5%. 3 of 8 shares, worth $1 each.$3
Series A30%. 3 of 10 shares, now worth $10 each.$30

That $30 is a paper value. It’s what her shares are worth at the investors’ price. She can’t spend it until the company sells or she sells shares. And in a sale, investors’ preferred stockThe shares investors usually buy. The charter gives them extra rights, often a preference in a sale and a choice to convert to common instead. usually gets paid first, so founders’ common stockThe basic shares founders and employees hold. In a sale, common usually gets paid after any preference the preferred stock keeps. can get less. Article #13 explains why.

When should you get an advisor?

There is no definitive answer. Watch for these signs:

  • A priced roundA financing where investors buy shares at a set price per share. values your shares in the millions.
  • Someone offers to buy some of your shares before an exit.
  • You’re deciding when to exercisePaying that fixed price to turn an option into actual shares. options, which can trigger tax.
  • You want to plan for QSBSA federal tax break that can exclude much or all of the gain on qualifying startup stock held long enough., gifts, or your family.

A tax advisor and a financial advisor help with these choices. Your lawyer advises on rights, approvals, and securities rules, and drafts the documents.

What if you don’t raise money?

Many founders bootstrap. Others borrow instead of selling shares. Either way, no new shares go out, so your slice stays the same size.

A loan on a plain promissory noteA signed promise to repay a loan, stating the amount, the interest, and when it’s due. isn’t ownership. The lender gets paid back with interest, not a slice. But the company must repay it, even in a bad year. A lender may also ask a founder to sign a personal guaranteeYour promise to repay the company’s loan yourself. The guarantee’s terms say when the lender can come to you, sometimes before the company runs dry.. Read that line carefully.

A convertible note is different. It starts as a loan but usually turns into shares at the next round. That’s dilution later, not no dilution. Article #12 covers notes and SAFEsA deal where an investor pays now for the right to get shares later, usually at a priced round. A sale or shutdown first can pay the investor in cash instead.. And even without investors, the poolShares set aside for future employee stock options., advisors, and early promises still shrink your slice.

What this means for you

  • Before each round: a fully diluted cap table that matches the signed papers.
  • Before signing a term sheet: work out what the price and the pool do to your slice.
  • After the round: update the cap table the day the papers are signed.

The takeaway

Your slice will shrink. That’s the price of a bigger pizza. Know which number you’re reading, and put every equity promise in writing.

Questions to bring to your lawyer

  1. How much of the company should we sell in this round, and what will it cost us in ownership?
  2. What will our SAFEs turn into when we raise a priced round?
  3. How big should our option pool be, and whose slice pays for it?
  1. 1. Facebook, “Facebook to Acquire WhatsApp,” press release, Feb. 19, 2014, https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1326801/000132680114000010/exhibit991_pressrelease219.htm.
  2. 2. Alexia Tsotsis, “WhatsApp’s Funding,” TechCrunch, Feb. 21, 2014, https://techcrunch.com/2014/02/21/whatsapp/amp/.
  3. 3. Susanna Kim, “WhatsApp Founder Was on Food Stamps, Rejected From Facebook,” ABC News, Feb. 20, 2014, https://www.goodmorningamerica.com/news/story/facebook-makes-billionaire-college-dropout-family-food-stamps-22601936.

Next: Crash Course for Founders #4, “When Dilution Hurts.”

Previous: Crash Course for Founders #2, “What Your Cap Table Counts.”

About the series

Every startup document reads well the day it’s signed. Far fewer still read well years later, and Yumeng Xu has seen the difference up close. Her path began with a clerkship at the federal court in San Francisco. It led to Section 11 securities class actions arising from IPOs, on the team defending directors and officers, and to complex trade‑secret matters. Today that experience goes to founders, on formation, equity, financing, hiring, and governance. It does the most good at the beginning, when getting it right costs the least. The Crash Course for Founders is that advice, in short lessons.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Reading it or contacting the firm doesn’t create an attorney‑client relationship. Please don’t send confidential details until we’ve confirmed we can help. Attorney Advertising.

Back to Articles