This article uses a corporation. An LLCA limited liability company, owned by members who hold units instead of stock. LLCs are usually taxed as partnerships, with their own rules. uses units instead of shares, but the math works the same way. The numbers are made up to keep the math simple.
How much of Facebook did Saverin own?
Being a co‑founder of Facebook is a good job. Owning 30 percent of Facebook is a better one. Eduardo Saverin had both, for a while, back in 2004. He was the business co‑founder and put in early money. After Facebook became a Delaware corporation, he held about 24 percent. Later, new shares went to others, and his stake fell below 10 percent.1 He sued, and the case settled. Dilution is normal. What hurt Saverin was getting none of the new shares. What could he have done differently?
When does dilution hurt?
Dilution costs you money when shares sell too cheaply. At a fair price, the company gets cash worth what it gives up. You lose some vote, but usually not value. Below a fair price, you lose vote and value. Saverin got none of the new Facebook shares. Delaware gives stockholders no automatic right to buy into new share issuances unless the charter grants one.
Investors protect themselves with anti-dilution terms. These kick in if a later round sells shares for less than the investors paid.
A full ratchet is the strongest protection. It resets the investor’s price to the new, lower price, however few shares are sold. An investor paid $2 a share. The next round is $1. The investor’s stock now converts into twice as many shares.
A weighted average is a milder protection. It moves the investor’s price only part of the way down. How far depends on how much cheaper the new shares are and how many are sold, compared with the shares already out. The charter sets the exact formula and exceptions.
Founders hold common stock. It has no such protection. Those extra shares are new, so everyone else’s slice shrinks, mostly the founders’. So founders push for a weighted average. Article #13 has more detail.
Watch the denominator
Your percentage is a fraction. Surprises hide in the bottom number.
- Promises. “1 percent” for an early engineer counts once someone asks.
- The pool. Investors often want a bigger pool before they invest. Those pool shares are added before the investors buy in. So the dilution falls on the existing owners, mostly the founders. The investors’ slice isn’t touched.
- Departed founders. If Wobble Bubble leaves early, the company usually has the right to buy back his unvested shares, often at what he paid, if it acts on time. There are alternatives. His agreement may speed up vestingVesting that speeds up, so some unvested shares vest early, often on a sale or a firing without cause. The agreement’s definitions control., for example if he’s fired without causeLet go for a reason other than what the agreement defines as “cause.” Each agreement sets its own definition.. The board can waive the buyback. Or the company can negotiate to buy his vested shares too. Any shares he keeps stay on the cap tableA list of who owns the company’s shares, options, and other rights to stock., and they still vote. Article #11 covers founder exits.
- Which total. Ask whether a percentage is of shares held today or fully diluted.
What this means for you
- Before signing a term sheet: check whether the anti-dilution is full ratchet or weighted average.
- Before the pool grows: ask whose slice pays for it.
- At formation: vesting and a buyback right for every founder.
- Always: put every equity promise in writing.
The takeaway
Dilution at a fair price is the cost of growth. It hurts when shares sell cheap, carry heavy preferences, or shift control. Read the anti-dilution clause, and watch the denominator.
Questions to bring to your lawyer
- Which of our existing deals have price-protection terms?
- Which terms in this term sheet cost me the most ownership?
- How does our buyback right work if a co‑founder leaves?
- 1. Nicholas Carlson, “How Mark Zuckerberg Booted His Co‑Founder Out of the Company,” Business Insider, May 15, 2012, https://www.businessinsider.com/how-mark-zuckerberg-booted-his-co-founder-out-of-the-company-2012-5.
Next: Crash Course for Founders #5, “Owning Isn’t Controlling.”
Previous: Crash Course for Founders #3, “Your First Round.”
About the series
Every startup document reads well the day it’s signed. Far fewer still read well years later, and Yumeng Xu has seen the difference up close. Her path began with a clerkship at the federal court in San Francisco. It led to Section 11 securities class actions arising from IPOs, on the team defending directors and officers, and to complex trade‑secret matters. Today that experience goes to founders, on formation, equity, financing, hiring, and governance. It does the most good at the beginning, when getting it right costs the least. The Crash Course for Founders is that advice, in short lessons.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Reading it or contacting the firm doesn’t create an attorney‑client relationship. Please don’t send confidential details until we’ve confirmed we can help. Attorney Advertising.