Certificate of IncorporationIPassignment?BylawsCap tableStock purchase agreementsBoard consentOffer lettersSAFE
“We’ll do the paperwork after launch.”

Crash Course for Founders · Capstone · Slice 1 of 6

Your startup is a stack of contracts

What legal documents does a startup actually need? The Winklevoss twins learned the answer in court.

November 20264 min read

This article uses a corporation as its example, whether Delaware or California, including benefit corporationsA for-profit company whose charter commits it to a public benefit as well as profit.. The six layers apply to every startup, but the documents change with the entity. An LLCA limited liability company, owned by members who hold units instead of stock. LLCs are usually taxed as partnerships, with their own rules. uses an operating agreementAn LLC’s main contract among its owners, covering ownership, management, and what happens when someone leaves. and membership units instead of bylawsThe company’s internal rulebook for how the board and stockholders meet, vote, and decide. and stock, and a nonprofit has no equity owners at all. California-specific points are noted where they apply.

How does a dorm-room idea become a $65 million fight?

One way to start a social network is to ask a classmate to help build one. The Winklevoss twins and Divya Narendra tried exactly that at Harvard, back in 2003. The classmate was Mark Zuckerberg. A year later, Zuckerberg launched Facebook. They sued, saying he took their idea. They settled in 2008 for cash and Facebook stock valued at $65 million. Then the twins spent three years trying to undo the deal, and lost.1 Whatever the four had agreed, it wasn’t clear enough to keep them out of court. So what should you sign, and when?

What is a startup’s legal foundation?

A startup’s legal foundation is the set of documents that decides who owns the company, who controls it, and who owns what it builds. Think of it as six layers.

LayerThe question it answersCore documents
CompanyDoes the company exist, and where?Certificate of incorporation (Delaware) or articles of incorporation (California), bylaws, initial board consent
OwnershipWho owns how much, and what happens if someone leaves?Founder stock purchase agreements with vesting, cap table
IPDoes the company own what you built?IP assignment from each founder
PeopleWho works here, and on what terms?Offer letters, inventions assignment agreements, contractor agreements
MoneyWho invested, and on what terms?SAFEs, convertible notes, stock purchase agreements, securities filings
ControlWho makes decisions?Board and stockholder consents, voting agreements

What happens without the documents?

Giggly Tickly and Wobble Bubble start a company called Boop Snoot on a handshake. They agree to split it 50/50 and build for eight months before incorporating. In month ten, Wobble Bubble wobbles off.

Month 0 · all smiles“50/50, partner!”Wobble Bubble · Giggly Tickly
Month 10 · Wobble Bubble wobbles off“I’m out. See ya!”Wobble Bubble · Giggly Tickly

Without the documents, Wobble Bubble may still own half the company. He may also own the code he wrote. When Giggly Tickly tries to raise money, investors pause until the questions are answered, and answering them takes Wobble Bubble’s cooperation.

No IP assignmentWobble Bubble takes the code
No vesting, shares leaveWobble Bubble wobbled off with half the company
Stuck“Come back when this is sorted.”Giggly Tickly can’t raise

With the documents, the company can buy back Wobble Bubble’s unvested shares, usually at the price he paid. The company must use that right on time, with the notice and payment the agreement requires. His code belongs to the company because he signed an IP assignmentA signed document that transfers the rights a person owns in code, designs, and other work to the company.. Giggly Tickly keeps building.

IP assignment signedWobble Bubble’s code stays
Unvested shares bought backBack to Boop Snoot, on time and in writing
Back to building“Shipping on Friday.”Giggly Tickly keeps going

What this means for you

  • Month one: certificate of incorporationThe document filed in Delaware that creates a corporation and sets basics like how many shares it can issue. (Delaware) or articles of incorporationCalifornia’s version of the certificate of incorporation, filed with the Secretary of State. (California), bylaws, initial board consentA written decision signed by the directors in place of a meeting. All directors usually must sign., founder stock purchase agreementsThe contract a founder signs to buy shares, including the vesting schedule and the company’s buyback right. with vestingEarning equity over time. For stock already issued, the company usually gets a right to buy back the unvested part if you leave. Options and RSUs that haven’t vested usually just end., spousal consentsA spouse’s signed agreement to the stock terms, since shares may be community property in California. from married or partnered founders, cap tableA list of who owns the company’s shares, options, and other rights to stock., IP assignment from each founder, and an EIN (the company’s federal tax ID).
  • Month one, in California: registration with the Secretary of State (Delaware corporations), then a Statement of InformationA short form filed with the California Secretary of State listing the company’s officers, directors, and addresses. within 90 days and every year after.
  • First hire or contractor: offer letters, inventions assignment agreementsAn agreement by which an employee or contractor gives the company what they create for it and keeps its information confidential., contractor agreements.
  • First customer: a customer agreement or terms of service, and a privacy policy if you collect personal information.
  • First check from an investor: SAFEsA deal where an investor pays now for the right to get shares later, usually at a priced round. A sale or shutdown first can pay the investor in cash instead., convertible notesA loan that usually turns into shares at the next round. A sale or the maturity date can come first, and then the note may be repaid or converted on its own terms., stock purchase agreements, securities filingsEvery sale of shares needs registration or an exemption. Some exemptions call for a notice, such as Form D or a state filing. Not every sale does., board and stockholder consentsA written decision signed by the owners in place of a meeting. The charter and the law set how many must sign and who gets notice., voting agreementsA contract among stockholders about how they will vote, often on who sits on the board..
  • Always: keep every signed copy in one folder. You will need them for every financing and every sale.

The takeaway

Your company is only as solid as the documents behind it. Sign the first three layers (company, ownership, and IP) in month one, while everyone still agrees and the paperwork costs the least. Already past the first line? It’s not too late. The sooner you sign, the cheaper it is.

Questions to bring to your lawyer

  1. Which missing document would cost us the most to fix later?
  2. Could a co‑founder, a contractor, or my old employer claim the code we built?
  3. Which of our documents are templates that don’t fit how we actually work?
  1. 1. Reuters, “Winklevoss Twins Must Live with Facebook Deal,” NBC News, April 11, 2011, https://www.nbcnews.com/news/amp/wbna42537372.

Next: Crash Course for Founders #2, “What Your Cap Table Counts.”

About the series

Every startup document reads well the day it’s signed. Far fewer still read well years later, and Yumeng Xu has seen the difference up close. Her path began with a clerkship at the federal court in San Francisco. It led to Section 11 securities class actions arising from IPOs, on the team defending directors and officers, and to complex trade‑secret matters. Today that experience goes to founders, on formation, equity, financing, hiring, and governance. It does the most good at the beginning, when getting it right costs the least. The Crash Course for Founders is that advice, in short lessons.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Reading it or contacting the firm doesn’t create an attorney‑client relationship. Please don’t send confidential details until we’ve confirmed we can help. Attorney Advertising.

Back to Articles